Home > PSB Lists >

PSB "singles" that weren't

As with most rock/pop acts with long histories and large catalogs, the Pet Shop Boys have recorded a number of songs that were at one point seriously considered or even earmarked for single release, but which for one reason or another never actually became singles. The following songs, listed in chronological order, are those that either were definitely or seem to have been slated—or, at the very least, considered—as singles but which never achieved that status.

Certain songs that were released as singles in only limited markets, but the single versions of which were widely distributed as imports—among them "One More Chance," "Paninaro," "To Step Aside," "London," and "Beautiful People"—are not included in this list. Also excluded are songs that a great many of their fans simply wish had been released as singles, but for which there's no solid evidence that the Pet Shop Boys themselves and/or their record company had seriously considered as single "candidates."

• Tonight Is Forever

  In the booklet accompanying the 2001 reissue of Please, Neil affirms, "This was so nearly the follow-up to 'West End Girls.'" But, as he and Chris then relate, their performance of it on the TV show The Tube proved to be, in their own words, "the worst television appearance we ever did in our entire life." Neil attributes this unfortunate occurrence to his having drunk four pints of beer shortly beforehand. "That's why," he asserts, "it wasn't a single." Neil's recollection may be slightly flawed since in a short interview on that same show he specifically states that "Tonight Is Forever" would not be the next single. Then again, just because it wouldn't be the next single doesn't mean they weren't thinking about releasing it as a single at some point.

• I Want a Lover

  Some copies of Please sold in Canada bore a sticker that called out four of its songs in particular: "West End Girls," "Opportunities," "Love Comes Quickly," and "I Want a Lover." Does this indicate that this latter song was at one time viewed as a prospective single as opposed to the song that would become the album's fourth and final single, "Suburbia"?

• In the Night

  A now highly collectible promo featuring this track was released in Germany, including an insert that identified it as an upcoming single. But it was never actually released as such.

• King's Cross

  Neil once said that it had been suggested to them that they release this Actually album track as a charity single in the wake of the disastrous November 18, 1987 fire at the King's Cross St. Pancras subway station, which killed 31 people and injured roughly a hundred more. But he and Chris rejected this idea, apparently for fear of possible accusations of capitalizing on the tragedy or perhaps even of having somehow predicted it.

• I Get Excited (You Get Excited Too)

  In the booklet accompanying the 2001 reissue of Introspective, Neil points out that an earlier incarnation of this song, from back in their Bobby 'O' days, had been planned as their third single following "West End Girls" and "One More Chance." That never materialized. Rather, it wound up as the b-side of the "Heart" single.

• Losing My Mind

  Although they had already pegged this Stephen Sondheim showtune as a strong candidate for their upcoming collaboration with Liza Minnelli, after recording their demo they seriously considered keeping it for themselves and releasing it as a single. Of course, they changed their minds and instead made it the lead single from Liza's album with them, Results. So, yes, it was a single—just not a PSB single.

• The End of the World

A reviewer of the newly released Behaviour album for the U.S. recording industry trade magazine Billboard singled this song out (pun intended) as a likely single. Billboard is generally disinclined to make such pronouncements without some "inside information." Sure enough, a list of upcoming single releases at the time from EMI/Parlophone reportedly included this song. Regardless, it never saw single release, though as far as I know there's never been any "official" public discussion as to why.

• Miserablism

  Co-producer Harold Faltermeyer apparently liked this track so much that he not only encouraged Chris and Neil to include it on Behaviour—for which it was in fact under serious consideration—but also lobbied for its release as a single. The Boys decided against including it on the album but reportedly continued to regard it for a while as a possible future non-album single. They finally determined, however, that it really wasn't "single material" (which, years later, Neil declared to be the right decision), so they instead employed it as the b-side of "Was It Worth It?"

• A Different Point of View

  Stickers attached to the cellophane wrapping surrounding the jewel case for the original CD release of Very stated that it "features" three songs: the album's two "advance" singles "Can You Forgive Her?" and "Go West" and a third, "A Different Point of View." This strongly suggests that somebody seriously regarded "A Different Point of View" as a likely third single. Yet that honor went instead to "I Wouldn't Normally Do This Kind of Thing." As it turns out, "A Different Point of View" was never released as a single at all.

• One and One Make Five

  The Boys have a very high opinion of this song. Chris has said of it, "musically it's a masterpiece." And Neil has noted, "When we did this track we thought this was the obvious single off the album but EMI couldn't hear it at all." Sure enough, while Very would go on to generate no fewer than five singles, this wasn't one of them.

• One in a Million

  Yet another "might-have-been single" from Very, Neil has described this song as "the Take That single that never was." He felt that he and Chris might produce a rendition performed by Take That, or perhaps even collaborate on it with them as co-performers. Neil asked the staff at Sarm West recording studio what they thought of the idea, and apparently received unanimous positive feedback. But Chris nipped that idea in the bud: "Well, we're still not doing it." He appears later, however, to have had second thoughts, admitting, "They would have done it rather well." But the moment had passed.

• One Thing Leads to Another

  The Boys considered putting out an alternate version of this Relentless closer—one in which the storyline is presented in the correct chronological order rather than in the reverse order of the released version—as a single geared for the U.S. market. But obviously that didn't happen.

• Discoteca

  There's some confusion about this one, both among fans and, it would seem, even among the Pet Shop Boys themselves. In the booklet accompanying the 2001 reissue of Bilingual with its Further Listening bonus disc, Chris says, "This wasn't a single, was it? We're mad." Neil then elaborates: "We tried to record a single version of it, because we thought it should be a single." Elsewhere (as in Daniel Rachel's book Isle of Noises: Conversations with Great British Songwriters) they've also specifically stated that "Discoteca" wasn't a single, despite their having once seriously considered it as such. But they did offer a "New Version" of the song and some remixes of it as bonus tracks with the "Single-Bilingual" single. As a result, that release is regarded by some as a "double a-side," like the earlier "Where the Streets Have No Name (I Can't Take My Eyes Off You)" paired with "How Can You Expect to Be Taken Seriously?" In light of various factors, however—not the least of them the Boys' own statements—it seems accurate to say that "Discoteca" should not be viewed as a single in its own right.

• It Always Comes as a Surprise

  Neil has said that he wanted this love song to be the first single off of Bilingual "but Chris wouldn't have it," adding, "We could never work out a good edit of it, anyway." A promo CD featuring just it and "A Red Letter Day" was, however, released exclusively in Brazil, where it had proven popular as an album cut, thereby generating further radio airplay.

• The Boy Who Couldn't Keep His Clothes On

  This song was originally released as a b-side/bonus track with the single of "A Red Letter Day." But somebody at Parlophone must have felt it had enough potential as a dance-club track to issue it, with most of its official mixes, as a 12-inch vinyl promo dance single, released to select dance DJs. Reportedly only 300 copies were made. If it had truly taken off as a popular number in dance clubs, it could well have seen wider full-fledged single release in its own right. Unfortunately, that didn't happen.

• Happiness Is an Option

  After they had recorded most of their album Nightlife, Neil and Chris were reportedly encouraged by their record company to add at least one more track specifically geared toward the U.S. singles market. As a result, they wrote and recorded "Happiness Is an Option." Perhaps they felt that its spoken verses were reminiscent of the "Brit rap" that characterized their first big hit (and U.S. #1) "West End Girls," albeit performed in a considerably more laid-back style. Whatever the case, they and/or their record company apparently felt it didn't do the trick after all—hence, not a single.

• Nightlife

  In the booklet that accompanied the reissue of the album Nightlife with its Further Listening bonus disc, Neil says of this song that he "always thought [it] might have been a single, so it didn't appear as a b-side for ages afterwards."

• Positive Role Model

  This song appears to have missed out on becoming a single not just once but twice. First, Neil and Chris recorded their orginal version of it in Berlin with producer Chris Zippel in late 2000 when they were planning a greatest hits collection following their album Nightlife. But that hits collection was postponed (emerging three years later as PopArt, but minus "Positive Role Model"), and their recording of the song instead became the b-side for the "London" single. Later, consideration was given to releasing the version recorded by Paul Keating from the Boys' stage musical Closer to Heaven as a single, but that came to naught as well. Although the PSB rendition appeared once again on Disco 3, single release was no longer in the cards.

• I Didn't Get Where I Am Today

  Regarding this song, Neil revealed to an interviewer for Classic Pop magazine (the May/June 2023 issue) that "We didn't put it on Release because it didn't fit the mood and wasn't on any of that album's b-sides as we always thought it could be a single." But instead it sat unused for a year-and-a-half until cropping up as a b-side after all for the single "Flamboyant." Neil now concedes that this was a missed opportunity: "If you want a great lost Pet Shop Boys single, I will totally go with 'I Didn't Get Where I Am Today.'"

• Party Song

  With an eye toward releasing the greatest hits album that eventually became PopArt, the Boys went into the studio to compose and record a song earmarked as a new single from that collection. "Party Song" was born of that effort. But though they created it specifically as a potential single, they (especially Neil) ended up not liking it very much. Therefore they squelched its single release and withheld it altogether until, a few years later, they repurposed it as a bonus track with the "Numb" single.

• No Time for Tears

  Chris and Neil viewed this song from their Battleship Potemkin score as a possible single, and they went so far as to commission a couple of remixes, including one specifically hallmarked as a "seven-inch" mix. Nevertheless, someone decided against releasing it as a single. Instead, it resurfaced as a "Minimal" b-side, which later earned it a spot on their Format collection.

• The Sodom and Gomorrah Show

  The Boys themselves wanted to release this song as the first single from Fundamental, and again commissioned a single mix. But their record company nixed it, fearing that no single with "Sodom" in its title would receive much airplay and become a bona fide hit. This refusal apparently remained a sore point with the Boys for some time thereafter. Later talking about it to an interviewer, Neil insisted, "It's not about having anal sex." Perhaps to spite their record company, they went on perform the song (as opposed to one of their actual singles) live when they appeared on U.S. television's The Late Late Show in November 2006.

• Vulnerable

  Neil stated in Issue 34 of their now-defunct Fan Club magazine Literally that he regarded this song as a serious contender for being the first single from their album Yes. He shared his opinion with record company personnel, who liked the idea and further suggested that it might be re-recorded and released as a duet. The Boys gave this some thought but finally decided against it. Duet or otherwise, "Vulnerable" never became a single.

• Pandemonium

  The Boys have asserted that they originally wrote this song as a possible single for Kylie Minogue. Instead they kept it for themselves. Considering they had thought it might make a good single for another artist, it seems a virtual certainty that they would also have given it serious consideration as a PSB single.

• The Way It Used to Be

In the booklet that accompanies the 2017 reissue of Yes, Neil said of this song, "We always thought it would be a single, but it's very long. Maybe we could have edited it down."

• Burn

  This track, which had all the makings of a major dance-club hit, was targeted as the fourth and final single from Super, likely to be released as such sometime between December 2016 and February 2017. But the widely publicized December 2, 2016 "Ghost Ship" fire in Oakland, California, in which 36 people died during a dance party, squelched those plans. As our musical heroes have noted, in the aftermath of such an event, any dance single with that title and the recurring line "We're gonna burn this disco down" would have been in terrible taste. So "Undertow" was released as a final Super "quasi-single" in its place ("quasi" because it was issued only as a download and on 12-inch vinyl as well as a CD with Annually 2017), with only a virtually unrecognizable bonus remix of "Burn" left to hint at its underlying tragic history.

• Ich bin Musik

  Although technically it might not have been a "Pet Shop Boys single," Frances Barber's recording of this Tennant-Lowe song from the 2019 one-woman stage show Musik was considered a strong enough candidate for single status for Neil to work with Pete Gleadall on an unreleased "single mix."

Honorable Mention:

• Shameless

  Neil has stated in hindsight (2023) that this song from the Very era, the b-side of "Go West," should probably have been a single in its own right. But he also gives the impression that this belief is indeed only in hindsight and that no one seemed to consider it seriously as a candidate for "singlehood" at the time.

 

---

All text on this website aside from direct quotations (such as of lyrics and of other nonoriginal content) is copyright © 2001-2024 by Wayne Studer. All Rights Reserved. All lyrics and images are copyright © their respective dates by their respective owners. Brief quotations and small, low-resolution images are used for identification and critical commentary, thereby constituting Fair Use under U.S. copyright law. Billboard chart data are copyright © their respective dates by Nielsen Business Media, Inc.