Home > Introspective >

Left to My Own Devices

Writers - Tennant/Lowe
First released - 1988
Original album - Introspective
Producer - Stephen Lipson, Trevor Horn
Subsequent albums - Discography, PopArt, Concrete, Pandemonium, Ultimate, Inner Sanctum, Smash
Other releases - single (UK #4, US #84, US Dance #8)

"'Left to My Own Devices' was an experiment in seeing how mundane a pop song could be, before setting it against extravagant music."
– Neil in the January 2011 issue of Word magazine

A strong contender for the single most dramatic track in the entire PSB catalogue.

So much is going on in this song that it's hard to know where to begin. For one thing, it's tempting to think that something very campy is going on in this recitation of everyday events given an epic, orchestra-on-the-dancefloor treatment (arranged by Richard Niles). Are the Pet Shop Boys implying that everyday life is epic in and of itself? On another front, one critic has described this song as indicative of the "desperation of the gay lifestyle," or some such rot. (Well, there may be a modicum of truth to it. Gay commentator Andrew Sullivan refers to it in this song as a form of "detachment" common among gay people.) One might even combine the aforementioned concepts and suggest that Neil and Chris are providing a camped-up parody of the epic self-referentialism to which certain gay men are inclined. Neil has gone as far as to say that it deals with someone who "goes through life always doing what he want[s] to do."

There's no denying the element of autobiography implicit in this song. For instance, Neil has said that he indeed played English Civil War general to his toy soldiers as a boy, as described in the song, although he admits that at the time he was actually a Cavalier rather than a Roundhead. (This isn't surprising considering that Neil was raised Catholic, and the Roundheads were fervently anti-Catholic. His more anti-monarchial leanings as an adult are likely what inspired him to shift his allegiance in the song to King Charles I's Roundhead opponents.) Neil's mother was reportedly rather upset when she first heard it (particularly by the lines beginning "I was a lonely boy…."), disheartened to think that he may have had a sad, troubled childhood. Another autobiographical aspect lies in the fact that, according to Neil, his "friend who's a party animal" is none other than well-known British music journalist/pop culture commentator Jon Savage. As for the famous couplet, perhaps the most famous and oft-quoted in the entire PSB corpus—

But in the back of my head I heard distant feet
Che Guevara and Debussy to a disco beat

—though inspired by the interests of the track's co-producer, Trevor Horn, it's perhaps as good an encapsulation of the Boys' typical musical style (revolutionary sensibilities set to a danceable, romantic, yet occasionally discordant setting) as anything else they themselves have stated so succinctly. The spoken lines toward the end about "Che Guevara's drinking tea … and takes to the stage in a secret life" apparently suggest that he has ceased actually being a "revolutionary" and has instead become a media celebrity: an image on t-shirts, an inspiration for one of the main characters in Evita. In this world, even the subversives get subverted.

And then there's the chorus, with its blasé, hesitant, but strangely affecting confession of love: "I could love you if I try—and I could. And left to my own devices, I probably would." (Some for whom English isn't their native language have wondered about the meaning of the title phrase. To be "left to one's own devices" is a common idiomatic expression meaning to be forced to rely upon oneself, particularly upon one's own plans and abilities. It can also mean simply, "If I had my own way.") It's terribly understated, and yet it's that very understatement that lends it power, as if the narrator can't help but concede his true feelings despite his seeming reluctance to do so.

At any rate, we're probably best off throwing up our hands and admitting that "Left to My Own Devices" is about a lot of different things, and just leave it at that.

Annotations

The song's title is a common English-language expression of uncertain age and origin, although "to be left to one's own devices" undoubtedly dates back at least to the mid-1700s. It generally has one of two closely related meanings. If someone is "left to his own devices," either he is permitted to do precisely as he pleases without anyone else's interference, or he is forced to fend for himself without any else's assistance. (In other words, he will devise his own way to deal with whatever situation is at hand.) The phrase might even be traced, with some variation, to the King James Version of the Bible, where in the book of Proverbs (1:31) it reads, "Therefore shall they eat of the fruit of their own way, and be filled with their own devices."
During the Boys' February 23, 2024 appearance on BBC Radio Two's Piano Room, Chris revealed an interesting fact about this recording. He said that, as he and Neil had first demoed "Devices," it originally had more of a "Motown feel" to it. But engineer and co-producer Steve Lipson then “housed it up," giving the final track its pronounced house-music vibe. His clients certainly must've liked it because they not only put it out it like that but they've also never released their demo, nor have they ever performed it live "Motown-style," at least as far as I'm aware.
"Turn on the news and drink some tea / Maybe if you're with me, we'll do some shopping" – Neil has said that he had originally planned to sing, "… we'll drink some coffee." He then decided to change it to "do some shopping," but not without some initial apprehension. As he once said, "I knew everyone would say it was pathetic—another Pet Shop Boys song mentioning shopping—but I decided 'coffee' was even more pathetic."
"Pick up a brochure about the sun / Learn to ignore what the photographer saw" – It has been suggested by more than one observer that these lines might allude to the British tabloid The Sun, which has been in operation since 1964 and which, at the time this song was written and recorded, had the largest circulation of any newspaper in Britain. It's notorious for its gossip about celebrities in general and—at least at one time, if not still—its dubious allegations about gay celebrities in particular. This possibility is especially pertinent in light of the line that immediately follows. This juxtaposed reference to a photographer strongly suggests paparazzi, which celebrities like Neil and Chris might indeed need to learn to ignore in order to maintain some semblance of composure in the face of repeated invasions of their privacy. For instance, in the late 1980s (again, around the time this song was recorded) the persistent and frequently false reports in The Sun about Elton John triggered a libel suit, resulting in a £1 million out-of-court settlement in Elton's favor and a printed apology from the tabloid. But, all that being said, if the Boys were indeed specifically referring to The Sun in these lines, wouldn't the words "the sun" be capitalized? Yet in the "official" lyrics (published on the PSB website) they're not capitalized. One can't ignore the possibility that these lines were meant to be ambiguous in nature, referring to the tabloid and/or to something else. It would appear that the sun reference instead (or "also" rather than "instead" if you go with the "intentional ambiguity" theory) refers to a holiday brochure. For instance, the U.K.-based travel/vacation company Thomson Holidays has published brochures titled Summer Sun and Winter Sun to promote their holiday excursion packages. Neil has in fact stated that he had recently picked up such travel brochures—specifically to Italy—only shortly before he sat down to compose the lyrics of this song and that had them in mind when he wrote these lines.
"I was always told that you should join a club" – Neil has noted that this line is "completely not true" about his own life, which underscores that, despite various blatantly autobiographical elements, this song's narrative persona is not Neil himself.
"In a secret life I was a Roundhead general" – The "Roundheads" were the pro-Parliamentary forces during the English Civil War of the mid-1600s. The name "Roundheads" came from the fact that they generally wore their hair trimmed short, unlike their opponents, the long-haired "Cavaliers" who supported King Charles I. (And in case you're not up on your British history, Charles I was ultimately defeated, deposed, and beheaded.) Again, Neil has pointed out that, as a child, he himself would actually have been far more sympathetic to the Cavaliers (in contrast to his more anti-royalist sympathies as an adult).
"Che Guevara and Debussy to a disco beat" – Ernesto "Che" Guevara (1928-1967) was a Marxist revolutionary born in Argentina who became a major figure in the Cuban Revolution of Fidel Castro. (His visage has become such a commonplace symbol of the counterculture that it's now a virtual cliché.) Claude Debussy (1862-1918) was a French composer, one of the leading figures of the impressionist movement (though he himself apparently disliked having the term "impressionist" applied to his own work). Both Guevara and Debussy may be viewed as revolutionaries in their respective realms. Their juxtaposition and association with a "disco beat" has often been interpreted—rightly or wrongly—as the Pet Shop Boys' own encapsulization of their musical style and ambitions.

It should be noted that, in July 2016, the track's co-producer Trevor Horn reminisced to interviewer Chris Payne that he had provided the inspiration for this line, a fact that Neil confirmed in his book One Hundred Lyrics and a Poem. While working together, Neil had apparently asked him, "What are you doing next, after this?" to which he replied, "I'm going to put Debussy to a disco beat." In return for using his words, the Boys awarded Horn a compositional co-credit (and its associated royalties) for the single's b-side, "The Sound of the Atom Splitting." And, as it turns out, Horn did indeed eventually put Debussy to a disco beat—namely, on the 1999 Art of Noise concept album The Seduction of Claude Debussy.
British operatic mezzo-soprano Sally Bradshaw provides prominent support vocals on this track. As Neil once stated, "The opera bit—'I would if I could'—is sung by the opera singer Sally Bradshaw. Trevor had the idea that she should sing 'house' at the beginning because there were lots of records in the chart at the time that would go 'house music.'" To be sure, "Left to My Own Devices," like most of Introspective, bears the strong influence of the house style of dance music.
Also in One Hundred Lyrics and a Poem, Neil points out that the last verse of "Left to My Own Devices" was taken from one of the first songs that he and Chris wrote together back in 1982, the unreleased "It's Not a Crime."
The "Disco Mix" (by Robin Hancock) of this song takes a cue from that same line to insert a few brief measures of a clearly Debussy-esque orchestral sequence immediately afterward. The quoted segment almost certainly comes from about two-thirds of the way through one of Debussy's most famous compositions, the 1894 Prélude à l'après-midi d'un faune ("Prelude to the Afternoon of a Faun").
In all likelihood it's completely coincidental, but it's an interesting coincidence nonetheless: this song's opening line, "I get out of bed at half past ten," echoes the refrain of the classic 1915 British music-hall parody number "Burlington Bertie from Bow," the narrator of which also boasts of his habit of not getting up until 10:30 in the morning. ("Thirty" of course provides a delightful rhyme with "Bertie.") It was famously performed by Julie Andrews in male attire in her 1968 film Star!

One of my site visitors has observed some congruence between "Left to My Own Devices" and the 1971 Stephen Sondheim song "Losing My Mind," which the Pet Shop Boys themselves recorded and which they produced as a hit single for Liza Minnelli in 1989, within a year or so of the Boys' writing and recording "Devices." Both songs detail the mundane tasks performed by their respective narrators during the course of a day, all the while describing the frustrations of being in love. My site visitor was even kind enough to put together a table that shows the parallels between these two songs:

Left to My Own Devices	Losing My Mind
"I get out of bed at half past ten"	"The sun comes up, I think about you"
"… drink some tea"	"The coffee cup, I think about you"
"… phone up a friend"	"I talk to friends"
"… fix some food"	"… doing every little chore"
"When I get home, it's late at night"	"I dim the lights"
"Maybe I'll sit up all night and day"	"Spend sleepless nights"

In addition, another site visitor has noted that "Could I Leave You," another song from Follies, the same Sondheim show from which "Losing My Mind" originated, might have inspired the recurring first line of the "Left to My Own Devices" chorus, "I could leave you." Whether all of these parallels are coincidental (unconscious influence or purely accidental) or intentional (a conscious influence or perhaps even something of a "tribute"), they're nevertheless fascinating.

Mixes/Versions

Officially released

Mixer: Trevor Horn and Stephen Lipson
- Album version (8:17)
  - Available on Introspective
- 7" Mix (4:47)
  - Available on Discography, Essential, and the Further Listening bonus disc with the Introspective reissue

Introspective Version - Edit (4:23)
- Available only on a rare 1988 U.S. vinyl promo

Mixer: Robin Hancock
- Disco Mix (11:29)
- Disco Mix Edit (4:53)
Mixer: Shep Pettibone
- Device Mix (7:38)
- Shep Pettibone Mix (9:23)
Mixer: Frankie Knuckles
- Frankie Knuckles Royal Piano Mix (8:20)
  - Available on the 2015 two-CD set House Masters: Frankie Knuckles
Mixer: Tim Weidner
- Live Concrete rendition (8:34)
Mixer: Stuart Price
- Pandemonium CD live version in medley with "Closer to Heaven" (5:40)
- Super Version (5:31)
  - Apparently a studio recording of the arrangement of the song used for the Super Tour
  - Released on limited-edition 12-inch vinyl and on a bonus CD accompanying the limited-edition 2017 hardback publication Annually
- Inner Sanctum CD live version (5:25)

Official but unreleased

Mixer: Frankie Knuckles
- Frankie Knuckles Temple L.A. Dub (7:29)
- Frankie Knuckles Orchestrated Devices (2:46)
- Frankie Knuckles 12-inch Nightclub Version (8:42)
- Frankie Knuckles 7-inch Radio Mix (4:45)
Mixer(s): unknown
- 12-inch Vocal Mix (9:23)
- 12-inch Dub Mix (7:43)
  - These two mixes appear on an official EMI Columbia reference CD by Capitol Mastering designed for client review before determing actual releases.
Mixer: Shep Pettibone
- Shep Pettibone 7-inch mix (4:23)
  - Appears on an official EMI reference CD by Abbey Road Studios designed for client review before determing the tracks for the 2001 reissues bonus Further Listening discs.

List cross-references

All text on this website aside from direct quotations (such as of lyrics and of other nonoriginal content) is copyright © 2001-2024 by Wayne Studer. All Rights Reserved. All lyrics and images are copyright © their respective dates by their respective owners. Brief quotations and small, low-resolution images are used for identification and critical commentary, thereby constituting Fair Use under U.S. copyright law. Billboard chart data are copyright © their respective dates by Billboard Media, LLC.